Some labors of love should be told to get lost. For Colored Girls, director Tyler Perry’s cinematic adaptation of the seminal 1970s play For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow Wasn’t Enuf, is that kind of well-intentioned, but doomed-from-the-start effort.
I have no doubt that the original work was very meaningful to Perry and his talented cast. But the play’s “choreopoem” structure—7 different actresses reciting poetic monologues that depict 20 unnamed characters—is nearly impossible to adapt. Perry chose to use 20 actors and give all the characters names and flesh out their stories. He also chose to occasionally have the actresses break the fourth wall and recite the plaintive, rhythmic dialogue from the play. It’s a risk that might’ve paid off in the hands of a more talented director, but here it just feels jarring and awkward.
Another problem: The film’s melodrama is piled on so thick, it borders on laughable. And the play’s themes of female empowerment are a bit...




