Evan Serpick's picture
February, 26th 2010

Maryland Senate Delegation Second Most Liberal in the Nation

cardinmikulski.jpgAccording to political magazine National Journal, Maryland's U.S. senators are among the most liberal in the nation. Sen. Ben Cardin tied with four other senators for the number-one slot, while Sen. Barbara Mikulski landed at number eight. Only Rhode Island—which had both of its senators tied with Cardin in the number-one slot—had a more liberal senate duo. Maryland's delegation to the House of Representatives ranked as the 6th most liberal in the country.

Depending on your political leanings, this will either come as an affirmation or a call to action in the coming elections. Check out the full rankings here.

[photo courtesy of the Women's Suburban Democratic Club of Montgomery County]

12:40 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
January, 21st 2010

The Sun: Crumbling Toward Embarrassment

sun1-21.jpgPerhaps you saw The Baltimore Sun this morning, with its lead story, "Ethics changes outlined for city." Sun editors are probably hoping you stopped there, lest you read the sub-headline: "Rawlings-Blake says her bill will seek to heighte public trus'." Now, I'm all for heighte-ing public trus', I just wonder when the city with lengthe the schoo' dayz?

All kidding aside, this is truly pathetic. The typos littering Sun stories in recent months have been one thing, but egregious mistakes such as these simply cannot be made on front-page headlines if a newspaper expects to be taken seriously. As a subscriber and diehard Sun booster—with many friends who work for the paper—it's painful to point out errors like this, along with the general decline in the quality of our city's newspaper of record.

But the pain is muted by anger: The Sun and its owners at The Tribune Company are largely to blame for the paper's sorry state. Yes, the newspaper industry is suffering nationally, but the decision by management at The Sun and Tribune Company to respond by decimating the paper's staff—including the virtual elimination of the copy editing department last April—are the direct cause of humiliating errors such as this one.

Management seems to have mistakenly calculated that it can keep the paper afloat by continually cutting back on writers and editors—the lifeblood of a newspaper—so long as it continues to crank out a product every day. If they continue to manage based on the that premise, the end is certainly nea

Click here to see our September cover story in The Sun's sad descent.

12:04 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
January, 19th 2010

Public Transportation Commute, Take 1

environmental_ccc_0.jpgUntil I moved back to Baltimore in 2008, the idea of driving to work every day was entirely foreign to me. After growing up in Pikesville, I went to college in New York and lived in or around the city until we moved back here. I took the subway—and for the last two years there, when we lived in Jersey City, the commuter PATH train—to work every day. During that time, I would occasionally grumble about the crowded trains and platforms, the delays, and—particularly in cold weather—the walks to and from stations. But the commute never took more than 30 or 40 minutes and I grew to really value the time it afforded me to read, rest, or just take a few minutes to space out and contemplate things.

After moving to Baltimore, this turned out to be a major adjustment. I'd like to say the environment was at the top of the list of reasons I hated driving to work every day, but, truth be told, it's near the bottom. For one thing, I hate having to deal with cars—they break down all the time, gas is expensive, you have to change the oil (apparently. I have yet to do this.) Also, my reading time has been drastically cut. My commute used to give me a solid hour a day of reading time. I used to get through a book every couple of weeks, read the paper more thoroughly, do the crossword—all of that is pretty much gone and I really miss it.

All of which explains why, when Baltimore city launched the Charm City Circulator last week, making it a lot more feasible for me to get to work using public transportation, I decided tyo give it a try. The Circulator consists of 21 electric-hybrid buses that, when the program is fully rolled out, will run on four routes through the downtown area—all for free! It's an ambitious, green initiative aimed at increasing tourism and use of public transportation and I think it's great. The orange line was the first to begin operation, on January 11th.

As it happens, the orange line solves the major problem keeping from using public transportation to get to work. I live in Mt Washington, about a mile from the light rail stop, but, until now, there was no easy way to get from the light rail stops downtown to my office in Harbor East. As it happens, the orange line runs right past the light rail's convention center stop and to Harbor East, about a block from my office. I decided to give the commute a try.

One thing I didn't realize was how accustomed I had become to having a car with me all the time. Every day since last Tuesday, I have thought about trying the commute, but inevitably there was some errand I needed to do before or after work or some meeting I needed to drive to that would make being without a car particularly inconvenient. Finally, this morning, I was ready to give it a try.

I decided to ease into the commute. Rather than walk or ride my bike to the light rail stop—it's not that far, but there's a brutal hill coming back—I would drive to the light rail stop and take public transport from there. I had a few things to take care of, so I didn't get to the light rail station until almost 9 a.m. when, to my dismay, the light rail parking lot was completely full. An adjacent lot had metered parking and a two-hour limit, as did all the other parking in nearby Mt. Washington Village. I could have searched farther afield for parking, but at this point, I decided to abort this first attempt.

Next time, I will have an earlier start and hopefully, I can find a spot at the parking lot. If not, I can probably find a spot on the streets near Mt. Washington Village. And, if all else fails, I can bite the bullet and ride my bike from home (which means investing in a lock—suffice it to say, I am a novice rider at absolute best). I perish the thought of coming home after a long day and having to slog up Sulgrave Ave., past Mt. Washinigton Elementary, but Lord knows, other people work a lot harder to go green. I'll report back on my efforts.

In the meantime, I'm curious of anyone else's efforts to use public transportation—particularly the Circulator—to commute in Baltimore. Of course, the packed parking lot could mean than more people are commuting to work—I've never seen the lot full before—but it could also discourage potential commuters like me. I wonder if there is any thought to expanding the existing lots to encourage more commuters. If it's possible, there ought to be.

1:53 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
January, 6th 2010

Sources Confirm: Dixon Resigns

According to sources at the courthouse, Mayor Sheila Dixon has agreed to resign from office.

Details have not been confirmed. This morning, the judge in the case had scheduled a hearing to consider a motion by Dixon's lawyers to throw our her conviction based on juror misconduct and confusing instructions to the jury. But the hearing never happened, as Dixon’s lawyers, state prosecutors, and, at times, Dixon herself, huddled at the courthouse all morning and into the afternoon, reportedly discussing a plea agreement in which Dixon would plead guilty to perjury charges, resign from office and, potentially, save her $80,000 a year pension from the city.

City Council President Stephanie Rawlings-Blake is in line to succeed Dixon upon her resignation. How the transfer of power will affect the city, the region, and attitudes toward Dixon and Rawlings-Blake remains to be seen.

Leave your thoughts and stay tuned...

3:25 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
January, 6th 2010

Dixon Resigns?

Mayor Sheila Dixon's lawyers, state prosecutors, and, at times, Dixon herself, have been huddling at the courthouse in downtown Baltimore all morning and into this afternoon, reportedly discussing a plea agreement in which Dixon would plead guilty to perjury charges, resign from office and, potentially, save her $80,000 a year pension from the city.

2:50 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
December, 17th 2009

Bmore Has Soccer Fever

chelseavert1-225x300.jpgIn July, when I went to M&T Bank Stadium to watch European soccer titans Chelsea and AC Milan play an exhibition game (left), I was blown away.

I knew Baltimore a passionate base of soccer enthusiasts, built around local haunts like Slainte, but nothing prepared me for the pandumonium on display. For one thing, all 70,000 tickets, ranging from $35 to $175, were sold out. But more shocking was the enthusiasm of the attendees. More than half were wearing either blue Chelsea jerseys or the black and red gear of AC Milan and hundreds had their bodies and/or faces painted in their team colors. The cheering was intense and sustained throughout the match

I spoke to a few of the attendees and they seemed evenly split between Baltimore-born folks who either play or played soccer or otherwise developed a passion for it over the years, and immigrants or children of immigrants from all over the world, who now lived in Baltimore or D.C., and were jazzed at the rare opportunity to see a world-class match.

Since the event, universally judged to be a massive financial and promotional success, local leaders have stepped up efforts to create a permanent soccer presence in Baltimore. In October,  Mayor Sheila Dixon sent a letter to the Maryland Stadium Authority, asking the body to study the possibility of building a new soccer stadium downtown to lure Major Soccer League franchise D.C. United—which has been unsatisfied with current negotiationms for a new home close to D.C.—to Charm City.

In addition, Baltimore is one of five U.S. cities in the running to host the 2018/2022 World Cup. You can sign the petition to bring the Cup to Baltimore here. The petition page includes some interesting facts about the history of soccer in Baltimore, including the following:

The city of Baltimore has long loved the game of soccer.

It was home to NPSL charter team Baltimore Bays.  In 1973, a then-record crowd of 24,680 watched as the Bays were defeated 6-4 by the Brazilian National Team lead by a thirty-three year old named Edison Arantes do Nascimento, Pele.

According to a report in the Baltimore Evening Sun, "Pele was mobbed by fans at the end of the game and escaped to the locker room attired only in a pair of black bikini briefs."

Currently, Baltimore is home to the Baltimore Blast of the NISL, Maryland Tigers of the PASL, Charm City FC of the NPSL and Crystal Palace Baltimore & Real Maryland Monarchs of the second division USL.

Our city's embrace of soccer is not entirely surprise. Within driving distance of Washington D.C., Philadelphia, and New York, Baltimore is an ideal regional location to draw fans of the international sport from each of those urban hubs. And, it goes without saying, Baltimore is a great sports town. If we can endure another 100-loss season for the Orioles, we can certainly endure our share of scoreless 90-minute soccer matches.

(photo courtesy udothedishes.com

6:38 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
December, 1st 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: What Happened in the Jury Room?

By Evan Serpick

So, the verdict is in. And now, observers are left to wonder what went on in the jury room over the seven days of deliberation. To quote Sun columnist and WYPR host Dan Rodricks, with whom I shared a courtroom bench on verdict day, "It would make a helluva movie."

I have my own theory about the gist of the deliberations and why the 12 men and women of the jury made the decision they did. I think a lot of city residents might have arrived at a similar verdict.

It's seems very likely to me that Mayor Dixon mis-used gift cards that she knew were intended to be given away to kids. In the case of the gift cards purchased by developer Patrick Turner, she specifically asked for them as giveaways and then used them for herself. Her contention that she thought the cards—which arrived in her office in an unmarked envelope days after she requested them—were an anonymous gift from developer/boyfriend Robert Lipscomb was far-fetched. Besides the timing of the request and the arrival of the gift cards, what kind of anonymous gift is a stack of $25 gift cards?

At the same time, I think the lengths to which Republican state prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh has gone to take down the popular Democratic mayor are appalling, and I bet the jury did too. His investigation opened over four years ago, when the mayor was an outspoken city council president. After spending millions of dollars in taxpayer money on the investigation, Rohrbaugh came up with $500 in mis-spent gift cards. If he cares so much about "the children of Baltimore," who he claims were victimized, he could have just given them a portion of the millions he's spent to take down a mayor who is largely seen as an effective, proactive voice in city government.

No one wants to outright ignore wrongdoing, but I'm guessing that some jury members were trying to balance their sense of immediate justice with a sense of broader justice. I think most, if not all, understand that the mayor had done something wrong. But I'd bet that many were leery of removing from office the first African-American woman to sit in the mayor's chair, particularly on charges that may seem like a petty or minor misapprpriation of funds.

After seven hard days of deliberations—the notes requesting smoke breaks might have set a record—the jury ultimately found an uneasy compromise. They convicted Mayor Dixon of one of the lesser charges she faced, acquited her of three others, and left one other undecided.

Mayor Dixon will likely have to step down in the coming days, but whether justice has been served remains a question for debate.

6:28 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
December, 1st 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Verdict In, Mayor to Step Down

By Evan Serpick, from Courthouse East

As the twelve jurors filed into the courtroom to deliver their verdict just after noon today, they seemed shell shocked, uncomfortable smiles on many of their faces. Then they delivered the news the city has been waiting for:

Mayor Sheila Dixon was convicted of embezzlement for using about $530 in Best Buy and Target gift cards, bought by developer Patrick Turner and intended for "the children of Baltimore." She was acquited of three other charges, including felony theft, the most serious charge,. The jury could not come to a verdict on another charge, that she embezzled gift cards intended for the city's Holly Trolley tour.

As a result of the conviction, the mayor will presumably have to step down, and City Council President Stephanie Rawlings-Blake will be sworn in as acting mayor. If Dixon appeals the conviction and is successful, her office will be restored. The sentence on the conviction will likely be a suspended sentence and restitution of funds.

Dixon displayed little emotion to the packed courthouse as the decision was read. While the heads of some of lawyers drooped at the conviction on count 4, the mayor's head remained high.

2:27 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
December, 1st 2009

Verdict In—Dixon Found Guilty of One Charge

The jury in is on Mayor Sheila Dixon's corruption charges. Of the five charges the Mayor was facing, she has been acquitted of charges 1 and 3—which alleged theft of gift cards— and charge 7, which alleged misconduct in office. She was found guilty of charge 4, fraudulent misappropriation by a fiduciary, meaning that the jury believed she received gift cards in her official capacity as council president but then used them for herself. A mistrial was declared on the second charge of fraudulent misappropriation by a fiduciary, which concerned a separate gift card. A fuller description of all the charges can be found here.

More news and analysis of the verdict will follow shortly.

1:59 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 25th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Deliberations Go On; Defense Requests Mistrial

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

Still no verdict, but legal wrangling broke the monotony of a fifth day of jury deliberations. Dixon's defense asked for a mistrial, arguing that the jury is clearly confused. The judge denied the motion. Now jurors want to review video playback of some testimony, which will take place in closed court this afternoon.

The media remains transfixed on the trial, whose jury deliberations are lasting nearly as long as the trial itself. TV reporters have set up practical news bureaus on the curb outside of the Calvert Street courthouse. Print reporters are phoning and texting updates to their newsrooms. For a sampling:

The Sun provides the most comprehensive coverage with easy links to stories dating back to 2006, when the Maryland State Prosecutor's investigation began.

WBAL is providing minute-by-minute tweets on the action (or inaction), plus links to longer takes from Jayne Miller and Dave Collins.

Other news websites offering comprehensive updates include: mddailyrecord.com, baltimorebrew.com, wjz.com, and foxbaltimore.com.

5:45 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 23rd 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: "Great Progress" and a Smoke Break

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

11:40 a.m.

The jury's latest note, read aloud at 11:40 a.m. by the judge, said the jury was "making great progress." It  requested a 15 to 20 minute break for jurors to get fresh air and to take "time to think."

"I personally need a smoke," read the note, penned by juror 12. Three others also wanted a cigarette.

12:45 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 23rd 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Deliberations, Questions Go On

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

The jury returned to its third day of deliberating Mayor Dixon's fate this morning at 9. So far, they have asked for several clarifications of legal terms, as well as a delineation of the role of the jury foreman.

Here's a recap of the notes jurors have been sent to the judge in earlier deliberations:
At 4:10 p.m. on Thursday, juror No. 4, who is the foreperson, wrote: "We need to close for the day. Things are getting a little out of order among us."

Before that, the jury questions focused on matters of law: "Does '...intent to deprive ...' or 'misappropriation' involved immediacy or a time period."

"Can we please get a law dictionary. There are some legal terms that some of us need explanation to. "

"Legal definition of misappropriation:"

The jury ended the day on Friday with a note similar to the one that ended the day on Thursday:

"Things are getting a little overheated. May we be dismissed for the day?"

11:34 am Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 20th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Jury Dismissed Until Monday

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

Jury says it's "overheated" and wants to be dismissed for the day.

Judge Sweeney sent them home until Monday at 9 a.m.

4:56 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 20th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Jury Still Deliberating

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

After ten hours of deliberations, the Dixon jury still has not reached a verdict.

"Keep praying," Dixon's attorney Arnold Weiner told a supporter of the mayor.

No matter the outcome, prosecutor Robert A. Rohrbaugh said Dixon's March trial for perjury charges is going forward as planned.

If the jury is hung, Rohrbaugh could also re-try the current theft case (which had been thrown out after Ronald Lipscomb failed to take the stand).

4:31 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 19th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Deliberations Continue

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

4:00 p.m.

The jury had a question, requiring all sides to return to court at around 315 p.m.

At that time, Judge Sweeney told the lawyers that the jury wanted a transcript of testimony. The request was denied. The jury was instructed to rely on their notes and memories.

But the brief meeting provided some levity when defense attorney Arnold Weiner's cell phone went off, just minutes after the bailiff warned the courtroom audience that phones would be confiscated if they rang.

A bailiff playfully marched over to Weiner and took his phone. Sweeney laughed and told him to return it. "This is your one warning," Sweeney told him.

Even Dixon was laughing.

For summary's sake, here are the charges that Mayor Dixon's jury is debating:

Counts 1 and 4 deal with the gift cards from Turner.

1: Theft. She stole gift cards valued at more than $500 from Turner by deception, that she solicited and obtained the cards under the false pretense that they would be used by the council president's office to aid the needy families of Baltimore.

4: Fraudulent misappropriation by a fiduciary.  That she received the cards from Turner in her official capacity as council president but that she then used them for herself.

The jury can not find Dixon guilty of both charges. If she is found guilty of one she must be found not guilty of the other.

Counts 3 and 6 deal with gift cards from the city's housing authority.

3: Theft. That Dixon knowingly stole cards purchased by the housing authority and that were given to her to distribute to the needy.

6: Fraudulent misappropriation by a fiduciary. As mayor she received the housing gift cards during the Holly Trolley tour for the purpose of giving them out to needy people, but she willfully used them for herself.

The jury can not find Dixon guilty of both charges. If she is found guilty of one she must be found not guilty of the other.

Count 7: Misconduct in office. That she abused her office by corruptly using the housing cards.

If Dixon is found not guilty of count 3 the jury must find her not guilty of this misconduct charge. If she is guilty of count 3 the jury must then decide whether she is guilty or not guilty of count seven.

5:30 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 19th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Closing Arguments End; Deliberations Begin

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

12:45 p.m.

The jury began deliberations at 12:30 p.m. after a morning of closing arguments. Dixon defense attorney Arnold Weiner said the prosecutors are asking the jury to decide Dixon's guilt based on their "imagination" not the "evidence" that she stole gift cards.

The packed courtroom laughed at several comments made by Weiner and even applauded lightly when he asked the jury to "end this nightmare" and the prosecution's "three and a half year pursuit."

Prosecutor Shelly Glenn gave the first closing argument. Maryland State Prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh provided the final words and said to steal gift cards meant for needy children is "unspeakable."

Rohrbaugh provided the most dramatic moment in the closings by snapping 19 best buy gift cards into a line atop the wooden rail in front of the jury.

Nineteen out of 20 gift cards were used by Dixon five days after developer Patrick Turner got a call from the then-City Council president asking him to purchase such cards for needy children.

"That's not a mistake," Rohrbaugh said.

Prosecutor Glenn told the jury that developer Patrick Turner testified that Dixon told him to buy the gift cards at Best Buy and Target. "Almost like she's phoning in her order," Glenn said.

Turner called Dixon's city-issued Blackberry at 11:04 a.m. on Dec. 13, 2005, slightly more than an hour before he bought $500 in gift cards at Best Buy at 12:21 p.m. About 40 minutes later, at 1:01 p.m., Turner bought $500 in gift cards at Target. At 1:21 p.m. Turner called Dixon again.

Glenn argued that it is reasonable to assume the two discussed the purchases given that timeline.  Turner could not remember the conversations, except to say that at some point Dixon asked him to buy gift cards for the needy. He was also unclear about how the cards were delivered to Dixon's City Council president office.

Dixon's defense has said that because the cards were delivered in a white envelope with her name on it but with no note or signature from Turner that Dixon assumed the cards were an anonymous gift from her former boyfriend, Ronald Lipscomb, also a developer.

The only evidence that Libscomb had given Dixon anonymous gifts was a floral arrangement delivered anonymously from him two years before Turner's cards arrived at City Hall.

The prosecution said none of that matters. The cards got to City Hall, Glenn said. "How do we know? She used them five days later," Glenn said.

The videocamera, camera bag, video tapes and other items purchased with 19 of the 20 Best Buy cards were found when prosecutors raided Dixon's home in 2008.

Dixon's Best Buy Rewards Zone card made tracing the gift cards to her easy, and Dixon does not dispute that she used the cards. Her only defense is that she thought they were hers to use.

Glenn said Dixon's argument that she didn't know Turner had given the cards is refuted by Turner's testimony that Dixon called again in December 2006 to ask him to donate gift cards for needy children again.

"You can't decide a case based on their imagination," Weiner said. "You decide it on the evidence."

He praised her years of public service and touted Dixon's pastor's testimony that she is an honest person. Weiner said Lipscomb's gift cards were the strongest part of the prosecution's case but that those charges were tossed. Now, he said, "you have the job of "remembering what you are supposed to forget" about Lipscomb.

The jury was instructed to disregard the testimony of six witnesses and more than 30 exhibits.

No one should have a verdict of guilt "based on reconstructed memory," Weiner said.

He said the office of state prosecutor disrespected Dixon by searching every "nook and cranny" of the mayor's home in 2008 with "reckless abandon."

"I ask you to return a verdict of not guilty," Weiner said. "To end this nightmare. To put the finishing point on a 3 1/2-year relentless pursuit."

Prosecutors, who have the right to present closing before and after the defense, ended where they started on Nov. 9: with Rohrbaugh invoking the needy children whom Dixon allegedly deprived of gifts at Christmas.

He said his office did not rush to judgment, which is why the probe lasted nearly four years.

The public would expect a thorough investigation. As for Dixon's confusion defense, Rohrbaugh said: "Do you really think the City Council president's office is that confused? There was no confusion."

The case, he said, "is about the citizens of Baltimore, it's about the children of Baltimore. They expect and demand the highest integrity."

1:52 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 18th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial Update: The Defense Rests

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

10:00 a.m.

Mayor Dixon's defense rested its case at 9:45 a.m. after calling two witnesses: a florist and Rev. Frank M Reid III, Dixon's pastor and spiritual adviser.

Judge Dennis Sweeney scheduled closing arguments for tomorrow morning. He sent the jury home so that the prosecutors and defense attorneys could devise final instructions to give to the jury before it begins deliberating the five charges against Dixon.

Dixon did not take the stand.

The owner of Flower Cart Inc. testified that in January 2004 Dixon's former boyfriend Ronald Lipscomb sent the then-City Council president a $285 flower arrangement. It was delivered to City Hall with a card that read: "To Sheila, Anonymous."

The defense has said that it would argue that Dixon used gift cards donated by developer Patrick Turner because she thought they were just another anonymous gift from Lipscomb.

So getting evidence in about an anonymous gift was crucial. The prosecutors objected to the florist's testimony but lost.

Maryland State Prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh gambled yesterday by not calling Lipscomb to the stand, taking away the defense's opportunity to make his relationship with Dixon a key part of the mayor's argument.

Sweeney then tossed the theft charge related to the gift cards donated by Lipscomb.

Rohrbaugh's only question to the florist was to reiterate that the floral arrangement was delivered in 2004, nearly two years before Turner's gift cards were delivered.

Reid testified that he knows Dixon to be "honest and forthright" in her many dealings with his church, Bethel AME in Baltimore.

Afterwards he told me that as spiritual adviser to Dixon he prays with her and tells her what Biblical scriptures to read, like the 23rd and 27th Psalms.

11:13 am Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 17th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Jury Dismissed for the Day

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

3:30 p.m.

Judge Sweeney sent the jury home at 3:15 p.m. after hearing two witnesses called by Dixon's team. The two were character witnesses and fellow members of Dixon's church, Bethel AME.

It took three bench conferences with the judge to decide how best to ask if Dixon is honest and charitable.

The prosecution asked one witness if she knew Dixon personally. She said, "No."

"I take it you haven't gone shopping with her (Dixon)," Rohrbaugh asked.

"No," said the witness, Karen Daniels.

6:06 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 17th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial: Some Charges Dismissed

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

After Robert Lipscomb failed to appear for the prosecution, Judge Sweeney agreed with Dixon's attorneys and dismissed the two charges related to the gift cards that Lipscomb gave to Dixon.

But he rejected Dixon's request to declare a mistrial and said the jury will decide the remaining charges related to the gift cards given by developer Patrick Turner and from the housing department.

Dixons defense will start afternoon.

The late morning legal tussle started after the jury was given a lunch break near 11a.m. Defense attorney Dale Kelberman said the state failed to show that Dixon ever directly spoke to Lipscomb to request gift cards.

"There is no evidence that Sheila Dixon made any misrepresentation or false statements to Ronald Lipscomb," Kelberman said.

Sweeney asked the defense if its theory is that Dixon couldn't distinguish between gift cards for the poor and personal ones because she was "swimming in gift cards?"

Kelberman said it doesn't matter if she was "swimming in them" or "wading" in them up to "her ankles." The point is that the state can not prove that Dixon knew Lipscomb intended the gift cards for the poor.

In granting Dixon's request to dismiss the two charges related to the Lipscomb gift cards, Judge Sweeney said:

"It would require speculation ... to decide what Mr. Lipscomb's wishes were (for the gift cards). It's a bridge too far. There is simply no evidence" that Dixon solicited the cards from Libscomb to be given to charity.

"There is basis for suspicion," Sweeney added.

In its request for a mistrial, Dixon's defense team also alleged misconduct by prosecutors. Kelberman said state prosecutor Robert Rohrbaugh knew from the start of the trial that he wouldn't be able to show a direct line between Lipscomb's intent for the cards and Dixon's personal use of them. That is why, Kelberman argued, Rohrbaugh never mentioned Libscomb in his opening statement even though Lipscomb is the alleged victim of one of the theft charges.

Rohrbaugh protested the allegation and said he was prepared to put Lipscomb on the witness stand. But that his trial tactics changed when Dixon's defense revealed that they would make their case about Lipscomb's many gifts to Dixon in order to show the mayor simply thought the cards were more gifts from the developer, who used to be her boyfriend.

There are still five charges pending.

2:27 pm Tags: Uncategorized
Evan Serpick's picture
November, 17th 2009

Sheila Dixon Trial Update: Surprise!

Our reporter Doug Donovan is sending updates from the coutroom throughout the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon.

11:00 a.m.

Major surprise this morning! The state rested at 10:53 a.m. without calling Ronald Libscomb.

Prosecutors called one witness, a Circuit City representative, this morning. The company official walked the jury through records that showed how Dixon and her driver, Howard Dixon (no relation), spent gift cards in December 2006 that had been purchased by Ronald Lipscomb's employee, Randell Finney.

The defense had no questions. After a few minutes of paperwork the state rested.

The jury was excused until 1 p.m. Once the jury had left Dixon lawyer Dale Kelberman asked for an acquittal. But the judge called for a five minute break.

12:05 pm Tags: Uncategorized